admin/BudgetApp
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

initial research

Browse Source
This commit is contained in:
teernisse
2026-01-12 00:36:55 +00:00
commit 2aa3320e6b
1 changed files with 535 additions and 0 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

535
adhd-budgeting-analysis.md Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,535 @@
# ADHD and Budgeting: A Comprehensive Analysis
## How Current Budgeting Apps Fail the ADHD Population and What Can Be Done
---
## Part 1: Understanding ADHD's Impact on Financial Behavior
### The Neuroscience of ADHD and Money
ADHD is fundamentally a disorder of executive function—the brain's management system that handles planning, organization, working memory, task initiation, time perception, and impulse control. These deficits create a perfect storm for financial difficulties.
#### Dopamine Dysregulation
The ADHD brain operates with altered dopamine pathways, leading to:
- **Preference for immediate rewards**: Research shows adults with ADHD are significantly more likely to choose smaller, immediate rewards over larger, delayed ones—a pattern called "delay discounting" ([Frontiers in Psychology, 2021](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11636743/))
- **Novelty-seeking behavior**: Lower basal dopamine activity drives a need for excitement, making shopping inherently appealing as a source of stimulation
- **Impaired reward prediction**: The brain struggles to maintain motivation for future financial goals when immediate purchases offer instant gratification
#### Executive Function Deficits
| Executive Function | Impact on Finances |
|-------------------|---------------------|
| **Working Memory** | Forgetting due dates, losing track of purchases, difficulty maintaining mental budgets |
| **Task Initiation** | Inability to start budgeting tasks, avoiding financial paperwork |
| **Planning/Organization** | Struggling with multi-step financial processes, disorganized records |
| **Impulse Control** | Spontaneous purchases, difficulty resisting sales or deals |
| **Time Perception** | "Time blindness" causing late payments, underestimating bill timing |
| **Emotional Regulation** | Using spending as emotional coping mechanism |
### The Hard Numbers
Research paints a stark picture of ADHD's financial impact:
- **65%** of adults with ADHD report difficulty managing finances due to impulse purchases ([Cash Essentials survey](https://cashessentials.org/cash-impulse-spending-and-adhd/))
- **4x more likely** to make frequent impulse purchases compared to neurotypical peers
- **£1,600-1,700/year** average additional cost from impulse spending and forgetfulness alone
- **65%** frequently exceed credit card limits; **55%** miss payments regularly (Dr. Barkley's research)
- **60%** have no savings account
- **3x more likely** to miss bill payments than adults without ADHD
- **£3,000+ additional credit card debt** compared to those without ADHD
### The "ADHD Tax"
Beyond impulse spending, people with ADHD pay hidden costs:
- Late payment fees from forgotten bills
- Overdraft charges
- Unused subscription fees (forgotten or too hard to cancel)
- Replacing lost or broken items
- Rush shipping fees from last-minute purchases
- Missed investment opportunities due to decision paralysis
- Higher interest from poor credit management
### Emotional Dimensions
#### The Shame Spiral
People with ADHD are far more likely to experience chronic shame. By age 10, the average child with ADHD has received approximately 20,000 corrective or negative comments. This shame extends to finances:
1. **Guilt after spending** → Buyer's remorse amplifies negative self-beliefs
2. **Avoidance of financial tasks** → Shame makes looking at accounts painful
3. **Self-medication through spending** → Using purchases to escape bad feelings
4. **Deeper shame** → The cycle continues
#### Emotional Spending
ADHD's emotional dysregulation creates vulnerability to "retail therapy":
- Shopping becomes a quick fix for stress, boredom, or sadness
- The dopamine rush from purchases temporarily soothes emotional discomfort
- This creates reinforcing patterns that are difficult to break
---
## Part 2: How Existing Budgeting Apps Fail ADHD Users
### Systemic Failures in Traditional Approaches
#### 1. **Complexity and Steep Learning Curves**
**The Problem**: Most budgeting apps (especially YNAB) require significant upfront investment:
- Complex setup processes with multiple steps
- Learning new methodologies (zero-based budgeting concepts)
- Remembering rules and categories
- Understanding financial terminology
**Why It Fails ADHD Users**: Task initiation is already impaired. Facing a complex setup creates an insurmountable "wall of awful"—the emotional barrier built from past failures, anticipated frustration, and shame. Many users never complete onboarding.
> "YNAB comes with a steep learning curve. And for it to work, you'll need to consistently dedicate time to updating it. Two things that don't bode well for it being the missing piece of the puzzle for an ADHDer!" — [Money Mindset Financial Coaching](https://www.moneymindsetfc.com/blog/the-best-finance-app-for-adhders)
#### 2. **Maintenance Burden and Manual Input**
**The Problem**: Even "automated" apps require:
- Regular transaction categorization
- Manual entry for cash transactions
- Reconciliation of bank sync errors
- Periodic budget adjustments
- Subscription management
**Why It Fails ADHD Users**:
- Working memory limitations make daily tracking impossible to sustain
- "Out of sight, out of mind" means if the app isn't constantly visible, it's forgotten
- Manual categorization is tedious, triggering ADHD aversion to boring tasks
- Bank sync failures create friction that derails usage entirely
> "No matter how hard I tried to track my expenses for 30 days, I'd lose track by Week 2 and end up spending way too much, too fast. Then the rest of the month? Total chaos."
#### 3. **Monthly Budget Paradigm**
**The Problem**: Most apps operate on 30-day budget cycles.
**Why It Fails ADHD Users**:
- Time blindness makes "30 days" feel abstract and distant
- Overspending early leaves weeks of scarcity (and shame)
- Monthly goals are too far away to provide dopamine motivation
- The wait between "budget periods" is too long for the ADHD reward system
> "Traditional budgeting fails spectacularly for ADHD brains because it demands sustained attention, detailed tracking, and fights against how your brain naturally works." — [ADDitude Magazine](https://www.additudemag.com/budgeting-tips-for-adhd-brains/)
#### 4. **Punitive Rather Than Supportive Design**
**The Problem**: Apps highlight:
- Red warnings when over budget
- Accumulating "failed" categories
- Negative balances and debt
- Historical patterns of overspending
**Why It Fails ADHD Users**:
- Shame-triggering feedback reinforces "I'm bad with money" beliefs
- Negative reinforcement doesn't work on dopamine-seeking brains
- Past failures being visible creates psychological barriers to engagement
- No celebration of small wins or progress
#### 5. **Insufficient or Poorly-Timed Notifications**
**The Problem**: Apps either:
- Send too many notifications (creating alert fatigue)
- Send notifications at unhelpful times
- Provide notifications without actionable context
- Don't account for when someone can actually act on information
**Why It Fails ADHD Users**:
- Alert fatigue leads to notifications being ignored entirely
- Notifications without immediate action capability are forgotten
- No integration with the moment of decision (at checkout)
- Bill reminders come too late to act on
#### 6. **Lack of Visual Engagement**
**The Problem**: Most budgeting apps use:
- Text-heavy interfaces
- Numerical tables and lists
- Static, utilitarian design
- Minimal use of color psychology
**Why It Fails ADHD Users**:
- Text-heavy interfaces don't capture attention
- Numbers without context don't create emotional connection
- Boring design provides no dopamine to sustain engagement
- Lack of visual hierarchy overwhelms with information
#### 7. **No Impulse-Intervention Mechanisms**
**The Problem**: Apps track spending *after* it happens. They don't:
- Intervene at the point of purchase decision
- Create friction before impulse buys
- Offer real-time guidance when shopping
- Provide accountability at critical moments
**Why It Fails ADHD Users**:
- Post-hoc tracking doesn't prevent impulsive behavior
- No support during the actual moment of vulnerability
- The dopamine rush happens before any app intervention
- Regret comes too late to change behavior
#### 8. **Ignoring Emotional and Psychological Dimensions**
**The Problem**: Apps treat budgeting as purely mathematical:
- No recognition of emotional spending patterns
- No mood tracking or correlation
- No support for the shame cycle
- No compassionate, understanding tone
**Why It Fails ADHD Users**:
- Finances are deeply emotional, not just numerical
- Emotional spending triggers need addressing, not just tracking
- Shame prevents engagement with judgmental interfaces
- No tools for self-compassion or growth mindset
#### 9. **Poor Integration with Daily Life**
**The Problem**: Budgeting apps exist as isolated tools:
- Separate from calendar, reminders, and task systems
- No connection to shopping apps or payment methods
- Require dedicated "budget time" that never happens
- Don't fit into existing routines or habits
**Why It Fails ADHD Users**:
- ADHD requires external scaffolding integrated into life
- Separate systems require remembering multiple tools
- "Budget time" is exactly the kind of task that gets infinitely delayed
- Friction between systems causes abandonment
#### 10. **One-Size-Fits-All Approaches**
**The Problem**: Apps assume:
- All users have consistent income patterns
- Everyone can follow the same methodology
- Standard categories work for everyone
- Motivation and capacity are constant
**Why It Fails ADHD Users**:
- ADHD symptoms fluctuate—capacity varies day to day
- Hyperfocus periods and low-energy periods need different approaches
- Medication timing affects decision-making ability
- Life with ADHD is inherently less predictable
---
## Part 3: Designing Budgeting Apps That Actually Work for ADHD
### Core Design Principles
#### 1. **Automation First, Manual Never**
**Implementation**:
- 100% automatic bank sync with zero manual categorization required
- AI-powered transaction categorization that learns and improves
- Automatic bill detection and scheduling
- Self-running subscription tracking and alerts
- "Zero maintenance" mode that works even when ignored
**Why It Works**: Bypasses executive function entirely. When money moves automatically, it doesn't require deciding, remembering, or initiating tasks.
#### 2. **Radical Simplification**
**Implementation**:
- Maximum 3-5 spending categories (not 50)
- Single-number "money available now" display
- One-tap interactions for everything
- Progressive disclosure—hide complexity until needed
- Default everything; let users customize only if they want
**Rationale**: Decision fatigue is real. Every choice is cognitive load. Simple systems get used; complex systems get abandoned.
#### 3. **Shorter Time Horizons**
**Implementation**:
- Weekly or even daily budget views as default
- "Money for today" and "money for this week" prominently displayed
- Break monthly bills into weekly "set-asides"
- Daily spending limits with visual countdown
- Immediate feedback on each transaction's impact
**Rationale**: Monthly is too abstract for time-blind brains. Weekly creates urgency without overwhelming. Daily makes spending feel real and consequential.
#### 4. **Gamification Done Right**
**Implementation**:
- Points/rewards for days under budget
- Streak tracking for positive behaviors (not punishment for breaking streaks)
- Level-up systems for sustained good habits
- Achievements for milestones (first $100 saved, week without impulse buy)
- Visual progress bars, not just numbers
- Celebration animations for wins
- "Power-ups" for using features like waiting periods
**Critical Point**: Gamification must be reward-focused, never punishment-focused. Losing a streak should prompt encouragement, not shame.
> "Gamified rewards like points, badges, and streaks tap into the brain's dopamine system... When users receive immediate feedback for small wins, they're more likely to stay engaged." — [Imaginovation](https://imaginovation.net/blog/gamification-adhd-apps-user-retention/)
#### 5. **Impulse-Buy Intervention System**
**Implementation**:
- Browser extension that adds friction to online shopping carts
- "Cooling off" period feature: save items to wishlist for 24-48 hours
- Real-time notification when approaching spending limits in-store
- "Is this worth X hours of work?" reframing at purchase moment
- Shopping list integration to distinguish planned vs. impulse purchases
- Voice-activated "talk me out of it" feature for temptation moments
**Rationale**: The only way to combat impulse buying is intervention *before* the dopamine hit of purchase. Post-purchase tracking is too late.
#### 6. **Emotional Intelligence**
**Implementation**:
- Mood check-ins: "How are you feeling today?" affects advice given
- Pattern recognition: "You tend to spend more when stressed on Thursdays"
- Compassionate messaging: Never shame, always encourage
- Celebration of progress, not comparison to ideals
- "Fresh start" features that don't carry forward past failures
- Growth mindset language: "Learning about your spending" not "Failing at budget"
**Rationale**: ADHD comes with emotional dysregulation. Apps must be emotionally intelligent partners, not judgmental accountants.
#### 7. **Visual-First Design**
**Implementation**:
- Color-coded spending (green/yellow/red zones instantly visible)
- Graph-based progress visualization
- Circular progress indicators for goals
- Photo-based transaction memory (what did I buy?)
- Visual timelines for upcoming bills
- Avatar/character that reacts to spending behavior
- Animations and motion to maintain engagement
**Rationale**: ADHD brains are often highly visual. Numbers don't create emotional connection; visuals do.
#### 8. **Hyper-Accessible Notifications**
**Implementation**:
- Smart notification timing based on user patterns
- Customizable notification styles (gentle, urgent, playful)
- One-tap actions directly from notifications
- "Snooze" that actually reschedules with a reminder
- Integration with smart speakers and wearables
- Morning financial brief: "Good morning, you have $X today"
- Pre-emptive warnings: "Rent due in 3 days, $X set aside"
**Rationale**: Notifications must come at the right time with the right information and enable immediate action.
#### 9. **Built-In Accountability**
**Implementation**:
- Optional "money buddy" sharing for accountability partners
- Social features connecting users with similar goals
- Body doubling integration for financial tasks
- Scheduled "money dates" with built-in guided reviews
- Professional connection options for ADHD coaches and therapists
**Rationale**: External accountability is crucial for ADHD. Apps should facilitate human connection, not replace it.
#### 10. **Flexibility for Fluctuating Capacity**
**Implementation**:
- "Low energy mode" with simplified interface and auto-decisions
- "I'm doing well" mode that unlocks more control
- Adjustable complexity based on current capacity
- No punishment for periods of disengagement
- Gentle re-engagement after absence: "Welcome back! Here's what happened"
- "Crisis mode" for overwhelming periods: just show bills and essentials
**Rationale**: ADHD capacity varies. Apps must adapt to users, not expect users to be consistently capable.
### Additional Feature Recommendations
#### Subscription Cemetery
- Automatic detection of unused subscriptions
- One-tap cancellation integration
- "Zombie subscription" alerts for services not accessed in 30+ days
#### Spending Forecasting
- Visual calendar showing money needs for the month
- Predicted low-money days highlighted
- "Future you" projections for saving/debt goals
#### Voice Control
- "Hey app, how much can I spend on lunch?"
- Voice logging for cash purchases
- Conversational budgeting interface
#### Smart Categorization
- Learn from user patterns, not rigid categories
- "This looks like a Target run" automatic splitting of large store purchases
- Emoji-based quick categorization
#### Positive Reinforcement Engine
- Daily wins notification: "You made good choices today"
- Weekly progress celebrations
- Comparison to past self, not others: "You spent 15% less this week than last month's average"
#### Forgiveness Features
- "Start fresh" button that doesn't delete data but emotionally resets
- Overspending treated as information, not failure
- "Learning moments" framing for financial mistakes
---
## Part 4: Existing Apps and Their ADHD-Suitability
### Quick Assessment of Popular Options
| App | Strengths for ADHD | Weaknesses for ADHD | Overall Rating |
|-----|-------------------|---------------------|----------------|
| **YNAB** | Zero-based methodology works once understood; good community | Steep learning curve; requires consistent manual effort | ⭐⭐⭐ |
| **Monarch Money** | Good automation; clean design; goal tracking | Still monthly-focused; subscription cost | ⭐⭐⭐½ |
| **Rocket Money** | Subscription cancellation; low maintenance | Limited budgeting features | ⭐⭐⭐ |
| **Weekly** | Weekly focus addresses time blindness | Limited features; newer app | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| **Simplifi** | Good automation; bill alerts | Paid-only; less engaging design | ⭐⭐⭐ |
**Verdict**: No existing app fully addresses ADHD needs. The ideal ADHD budgeting app has yet to be built.
---
## Part 5: Call to Action for App Developers
### The Market Opportunity
- **6-7% of adults** have ADHD (often undiagnosed)
- **47%** of adults with ADHD report dissatisfaction with money management
- This represents millions of underserved users actively seeking solutions
- ADHD adults are willing to pay for tools that actually work for their brains
- First-mover advantage in ADHD-specific financial tools is significant
### Key Differentiators for Success
1. **Market as "Built for ADHD Brains"** — explicit positioning resonates
2. **Involve ADHD users in design** — nothing about us without us
3. **Partner with ADHD coaches and therapists** for distribution and credibility
4. **Measure success differently** — engagement over precision; improvement over perfection
5. **Build community** — peer support is powerful for this population
---
## Conclusion
Traditional budgeting apps are designed by and for neurotypical brains. They assume consistent motivation, reliable memory, steady emotional regulation, and natural resistance to impulses—all things that ADHD directly impairs.
The result is that people with ADHD face a double burden: not only do they struggle more with financial management, but the tools designed to help actively work against their neurology.
The solution isn't asking people with ADHD to "try harder" at conventional apps. It's building apps that work with ADHD brains—apps that are automatic, visual, immediate, forgiving, engaging, and emotionally intelligent.
The technology exists. The understanding of ADHD exists. What's missing is apps that bring these together.
---
## Part 6: Personal Needs Profile (Interview Results)
The following profile was developed through an in-depth interview with an individual with ADHD about their specific budgeting needs and experiences.
### Struggles Experienced
This person experiences **all four major ADHD financial challenges**:
- **Impulse buying** - particularly triggered by emotional moments, in-store shopping (the "Target trap"), and discovering novel/interesting items
- **Forgetting bills** - leading to late fees and stress
- **Task initiation paralysis** - knowing they should budget but unable to start
- **Emotional spending** - using purchases as a coping mechanism
### Past App Failures
Previous budgeting app attempts have failed due to:
- **Setup complexity** - losing steam during onboarding before finishing configuration
- **Maintenance burden** - transaction categorization becoming overwhelming over time
- **Shame spiral** - seeing overspending triggers avoidance of the app entirely
### Core Feature Requirements
#### The "Safe to Spend" Number
The most important feature is a **single, immediately visible number** showing money available to spend without impacting bills or savings. Context preferences:
- **Weekly countdown**: "$180 until Sunday" - weekly focus with clear timeline
- **Percentage visualization**: "You've used 60% of your weekly fun money" with visual progress bar
#### Three-Zone Money Architecture
The app should divide money into three distinct protected zones:
1. **Locked Zone** - Bills and essential expenses (highest protection, serious warnings if touched)
2. **Goals Zone** - Savings and financial goals (moderate protection)
3. **Free Zone** - Discretionary spending (the "safe to spend" number)
**Important insight**: The user believes some guilt is appropriate when spending invades bill money. The app shouldn't be relentlessly positive - serious consequences deserve serious treatment.
#### Wishlist with Cooling-Off Period
A dedicated place to capture "things I want to buy" in the moment, with:
- 24-72 hour mandatory waiting period before purchase is "allowed"
- Easy capture mechanism (photo or voice?)
- Review system to evaluate if desire persists
#### Savings Motivation Features
What would actually motivate saving:
- **Visual goal progress** - filling jars, growing plants, building something tangible
- **Savings streaks** - consecutive days/weeks hitting targets with streak counter
- **Future projections** - "At this rate, you'll have $X in 6 months"
*Not* interested in invisible micro-savings - wants to feel involved and see progress actively.
#### Subscription Management
Zombie subscriptions are a **major problem**. Needs:
- Automatic detection of unused subscriptions
- Easy cancellation workflow
- Alerts for services not accessed in 30+ days
#### Income Handling
- **Primary**: Steady paycheck on predictable schedule
- **Secondary**: Random supplementary income (side business, etc.)
Bonus money currently has no clear destination. Would benefit from a "bonus money router" that prompts where extra income should go when it arrives.
#### Engagement Model
Would interact with a well-designed app at multiple levels:
- **Quick daily glance** - see the single number in <30 seconds
- **Pre-purchase checks** - multiple times daily if fast and frictionless
- **Weekly review session** - deeper engagement with trends and planning
#### What Would Create Long-Term Stickiness
For this person to actually stick with an app long-term, it must:
- **Be genuinely entertaining** - not just "useful"
- **Show them winning** - focus on progress and wins, not failures
- **Require zero effort** - work even during periods of disengagement
- **Connect to their goals** - tie spending to things they care about achieving
### Design Implications
Based on this interview, an ideal app for this user would:
1. **Open to a single bold number** - weekly "safe to spend" with percentage bar
2. **Three-tap depth** - glance view → spending view → full review
3. **Wishlist friction** - easy to add items, delayed ability to purchase
4. **Visual savings** - animated progress toward concrete goals
5. **Subscription graveyard** - aggressive detection and easy cancellation
6. **Bonus money flow** - prompt when extra income detected
7. **Appropriate severity** - gentle for fun money overspending, serious for bill territory invasion
8. **Zero-maintenance operation** - continues working if ignored for days
9. **Entertainment value** - gamification, personality, visual delight
10. **Goal connection** - always visible link between spending and what they're working toward
---
## Sources
- [Relational Psych - How ADHD Affects Financial Management](https://www.relationalpsych.group/articles/how-adhd-affects-financial-management-and-spending-habits)
- [PMC - Impulsive Buying and Deferment of Gratification Among Adults With ADHD](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11636743/)
- [Cash Essentials - Cash, Impulse Spending, and ADHD](https://cashessentials.org/cash-impulse-spending-and-adhd/)
- [ADDitude Magazine - Budgeting Tips for ADHD Brains](https://www.additudemag.com/budgeting-tips-for-adhd-brains/)
- [ADDitude Magazine - Impulse Buying Money Problems](https://www.additudemag.com/impulse-buying-money-problems-adhd-adults/)
- [Money Mindset Financial Coaching - Best Finance App for ADHDers](https://www.moneymindsetfc.com/blog/the-best-finance-app-for-adhders)
- [YNAB - Budgeting with ADHD](https://www.ynab.com/blog/budgeting-with-adhd)
- [Imaginovation - Gamification in ADHD Apps](https://imaginovation.net/blog/gamification-adhd-apps-user-retention/)
- [Tiimo - Gamification ADHD](https://www.tiimoapp.com/resource-hub/gamification-adhd)
- [Tiimo - Task Initiation ADHD](https://www.tiimoapp.com/resource-hub/task-initiation-adhd)
- [Cleveland Clinic - ADHD and Emotional Dysregulation](https://health.clevelandclinic.org/adhd-and-emotional-dysregulation)
- [Shift Collab - ADHD and Money Stress](https://www.shiftcollab.com/blog/adhd-and-money-stress-how-adhd-affects-spending-saving-and-financial-planning-and-what-you-can-do-about-it)
- [ADHD Specialist - Overspending and Impulsivity](https://adhdspecialist.com/post/adhd-overspending-and-impulsivity)
- [Medium - Dopamine ADHD and Impulse Spending](https://medium.com/cognitive-neuroeconomics/dopamine-adhd-and-impulse-spending-4043af55b407)
- [Asper - Best Budget Apps for ADHD 2025](https://asper.app/best-budget-apps-for-adhd-engaging-tools-for-2025-asper/)
- [ADD Resource Center - Managing ADHD Finances](https://www.addrc.org/managing-adhd-finances-the-no-budget-system-that-actually-works/)