# MR Pipeline Efficiency

- **Command:** `lore mr-pipeline [--since <date>]`
- **Confidence:** 78%
- **Tier:** 3
- **Status:** proposed
- **Effort:** medium — builds on bottleneck detector with more stages

## What

Track the full MR lifecycle: creation, first review, all reviews complete (threads
resolved), approval, merge. Compute time spent in each stage across all MRs.
Identify which stage is the bottleneck.

## Why

"Our merge process is slow" is vague. This breaks it into stages so teams can target
the actual bottleneck. Maybe creation-to-review is fast but review-to-merge is slow
(merge queue issues). Maybe first review is fast but resolution takes forever
(contentious code).

## Data Required

All exists today:
- `merge_requests` (created_at, merged_at)
- `notes` (note_type='DiffNote', created_at, author_username)
- `discussions` (resolved, resolvable, merge_request_id)
- `resource_state_events` (state changes with timestamps)

## Implementation Sketch

For each merged MR, compute:
1. **Created → First Review**: MIN(DiffNote.created_at) - mr.created_at
2. **First Review → All Resolved**: MAX(discussion.resolved_at) - MIN(DiffNote.created_at)
3. **All Resolved → Merged**: mr.merged_at - MAX(discussion.resolved_at)

Note: "resolved_at" isn't directly stored but can be approximated from the last
note in resolved discussions, or from state events.

## Human Output

```
MR Pipeline (last 30 days, 24 merged MRs)

  Stage                    Median    P75      P90
  Created → First Review   4.2h     12.1h    28.3h
  First Review → Resolved  8.1h     24.5h    72.0h    <-- BOTTLENECK
  Resolved → Merged        0.5h      1.2h     3.1h

  Total (Created → Merged) 18.4h    48.2h    96.1h

  Biggest bottleneck: Review resolution (median 8.1h)
  Suggestion: Consider breaking large MRs into smaller reviewable chunks
```

## Downsides

- "Resolved" timestamp approximation may be inaccurate
- Pipeline assumes linear flow; real MRs have back-and-forth cycles
- Draft MRs skew metrics (created early, reviewed late intentionally)

## Extensions

- `lore mr-pipeline --exclude-drafts` — cleaner metrics
- Per-project comparison: which project has the fastest pipeline?
- Trend line: weekly pipeline speed over time
- Break down by MR size (files changed) to normalize