Files
gitlore/docs/ideas/project-ergonomics.md
Taylor Eernisse 4185abe05d docs: add feature ideas catalog, time-decay scoring plan, and timeline issue doc
Ideas catalog (docs/ideas/): 25 feature concept documents covering future
lore capabilities including bottleneck detection, churn analysis, expert
scoring, collaboration patterns, milestone risk, knowledge silos, and more.
Each doc includes motivation, implementation sketch, data requirements, and
dependencies on existing infrastructure. README.md provides an overview and
SYSTEM-PROPOSAL.md presents the unified analytics vision.

Plans (plans/): Time-decay expert scoring design with four rounds of review
feedback exploring decay functions, scoring algebra, and integration points
with the existing who-expert pipeline.

Issue doc (docs/issues/001): Documents the timeline pipeline bug where
EntityRef was missing project context, causing ambiguous cross-project
references during the EXPAND stage.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-02-09 10:16:48 -05:00

266 lines
8.2 KiB
Markdown

# Multi-Project Ergonomics
- **Confidence:** 90%
- **Tier:** 1
- **Status:** proposed
- **Effort:** medium (multiple small improvements that compound)
## The Problem
Every command that touches project-scoped data requires `-p group/subgroup/project`
to disambiguate. For users with 5+ projects synced, this is:
- Repetitive: typing `-p infra/platform/auth-service` on every query
- Error-prone: mistyping long paths
- Discoverable only by failure: you don't know you need `-p` until you hit an
ambiguous error
The fuzzy matching in `resolve_project` is already good (suffix, substring,
case-insensitive) but it only kicks in on the `-p` value itself. There's no way to
set a default, group projects, or scope a whole session.
## Proposed Improvements
### 1. Project Aliases in Config
Let users define short aliases for long project paths.
```json
{
"projects": [
{ "path": "infra/platform/auth-service", "alias": "auth" },
{ "path": "infra/platform/billing-service", "alias": "billing" },
{ "path": "frontend/customer-portal", "alias": "portal" },
{ "path": "frontend/admin-dashboard", "alias": "admin" }
]
}
```
Then: `lore issues -p auth` resolves via alias before falling through to fuzzy match.
**Implementation:** Add optional `alias` field to `ProjectConfig`. In
`resolve_project`, check aliases before the existing exact/suffix/substring cascade.
```rust
#[derive(Debug, Clone, Deserialize)]
pub struct ProjectConfig {
pub path: String,
#[serde(default)]
pub alias: Option<String>,
}
```
Resolution order becomes:
1. Exact alias match (new)
2. Exact path match
3. Case-insensitive path match
4. Suffix match
5. Substring match
### 2. Default Project (`LORE_PROJECT` env var)
Set a default project for your shell session so you don't need `-p` at all.
```bash
export LORE_PROJECT=auth
lore issues # scoped to auth-service
lore mrs --state opened # scoped to auth-service
lore search "timeout bug" # scoped to auth-service
lore issues -p billing # explicit -p overrides the env var
```
**Implementation:** In every command that accepts `-p`, fall back to
`std::env::var("LORE_PROJECT")` when the flag is absent. The `-p` flag always wins.
Could also support a config-level default:
```json
{
"defaultProject": "auth"
}
```
Precedence: CLI flag > env var > config default > (no filter).
### 3. `lore use <project>` — Session Context Switcher
A command that sets `LORE_PROJECT` for the current shell by writing to a dotfile.
```bash
lore use auth
# writes ~/.local/state/lore/current-project containing "auth"
lore issues # reads current-project file, scopes to auth
lore use --clear # removes the file, back to all-project mode
lore use # shows current project context
```
This is similar to `kubectl config use-context`, `nvm use`, or `tfenv use`.
**Implementation:** Write a one-line file at a known state path. Each command reads
it as the lowest-priority default (below env var and CLI flag).
Precedence: CLI flag > env var > `lore use` state file > config default > (no filter).
### 4. `lore projects` — Project Listing and Discovery
A dedicated command to see what's synced, with aliases and activity stats.
```bash
$ lore projects
Alias Path Issues MRs Last Sync
auth infra/platform/auth-service 142 87 2h ago
billing infra/platform/billing-service 56 34 2h ago
portal frontend/customer-portal 203 112 2h ago
admin frontend/admin-dashboard 28 15 3d ago
- data/ml-pipeline 89 45 2h ago
```
Robot mode returns the same as JSON with alias, path, counts, and last sync time.
**Implementation:** Query `projects` joined with `COUNT(issues)`, `COUNT(mrs)`,
and `MAX(sync_runs.finished_at)`. Overlay aliases from config.
### 5. Project Groups in Config
Let users define named groups of projects for batch scoping.
```json
{
"projectGroups": {
"backend": ["auth", "billing", "data/ml-pipeline"],
"frontend": ["portal", "admin"],
"all-infra": ["auth", "billing"]
}
}
```
Then: `lore issues -p @backend` (or `--group backend`) queries across all projects
in the group.
**Implementation:** When `-p` value starts with `@`, look up the group and resolve
each member project. Pass as a `Vec<i64>` of project IDs to the query layer.
This is especially powerful for:
- `lore search "auth bug" -p @backend` — search across related repos
- `lore digest --since 7d -p @frontend` — team-scoped activity digest
- `lore timeline "deployment" -p @all-infra` — cross-repo timeline
### 6. Git-Aware Project Detection
When running `lore` from inside a git repo that matches a synced project, auto-scope
to that project without any flags.
```bash
cd ~/code/auth-service
lore issues # auto-detects this is infra/platform/auth-service
```
**Implementation:** Read `.git/config` for the remote URL, extract the project path,
check if it matches a synced project. Only activate when exactly one project matches.
Detection logic:
```
1. Check if cwd is inside a git repo (find .git)
2. Parse git remote origin URL
3. Extract path component (e.g., "infra/platform/auth-service.git" → "infra/platform/auth-service")
4. Match against synced projects
5. If exactly one match, use as implicit -p
6. If ambiguous or no match, do nothing (fall through to normal behavior)
```
Precedence: CLI flag > env var > `lore use` > config default > git detection > (no filter).
This is similar to how `gh` (GitHub CLI) auto-detects the repo you're in.
### 7. Prompt Integration / Shell Function
Provide a shell function that shows the current project context in the prompt.
```bash
# In .bashrc / .zshrc
eval "$(lore completions zsh)"
PROMPT='$(lore-prompt)%~ %# '
```
Output: `[lore:auth] ~/code/auth-service %`
Shows which project `lore` commands will scope to, using the same precedence chain.
Helps users understand what context they're in before running a query.
### 8. Short Project References in Output
Once aliases exist, use them everywhere in output for brevity:
**Before:**
```
infra/platform/auth-service#42 Login timeout bug
infra/platform/auth-service!234 Refactor auth middleware
```
**After:**
```
auth#42 Login timeout bug
auth!234 Refactor auth middleware
```
With `--full-paths` flag to get the verbose form when needed.
## Combined UX Flow
With all improvements, a typical session looks like:
```bash
# One-time config
lore init # sets up aliases during interactive setup
# Daily use
lore use auth # set context
lore issues --state opened # no -p needed
lore search "timeout" # scoped to auth
lore timeline "login flow" # scoped to auth
lore issues -p @backend # cross-repo query via group
lore mrs -p billing # quick alias switch
lore use --clear # back to global
```
Or for the power user who never wants to type `lore use`:
```bash
cd ~/code/auth-service
lore issues # git-aware auto-detection
```
Or for the scripter:
```bash
LORE_PROJECT=auth lore --robot issues -n 50 # env var for automation
```
## Priority Order
Implement in this order for maximum incremental value:
1. **Project aliases** — smallest change, biggest daily friction reduction
2. **`LORE_PROJECT` env var** — trivial to implement, enables scripting
3. **`lore projects` command** — discoverability, completes the alias story
4. **`lore use` context** — nice-to-have for heavy users
5. **Project groups** — high value for multi-repo teams
6. **Git-aware detection** — polish, "it just works" feel
7. **Short refs in output** — ties into timeline issue #001
8. **Prompt integration** — extra polish
## Relationship to Issue #001
The timeline entity-ref ambiguity (issue #001) is solved naturally by items 7 and 8
here. Once aliases exist, `format_entity_ref` can use the alias as the short project
identifier in multi-project output:
```
auth#42 instead of infra/platform/auth-service#42
```
And in single-project timelines (detected via `lore use` or git-aware), the project
prefix is omitted entirely — matching the current behavior but now intentionally.